What are AR Coatings and how are they used with Synthetic Sapphire in various applications?
If you want to learn more, you’re in the right place.
The AR Coating with Synthetic Sapphire story
Overview
This paper provides an overview of AR coating and how it can be used with synthetic sapphire. Additionally, we will review the properties, benefits, and types of AR coating along with various applications for its use.
Understanding Synthetic Sapphire and AR Coating
Synthetic sapphire is useful in many applications requiring hardness and chemical inertness. Coupling the mechanical advantages of sapphire with the material’s optical properties as a window material supports applications that require protection of visual arrays, e.g., mobile phone screens, wrist watches, or isolation of environments where optical techniques are used to measure or modify within the isolated environment, e.g., flow cells. Depending on the application, high optical efficiencies and/or reduction of stray light may require anti-reflective (AR) coatings to enhance sapphire window performance. We will discuss the physics of AR coatings and how they improve transmission efficiency and reduce stray light.
The first documented observation of AR coating behavior was recorded by John William Strutt Rayleigh in 1886 when he noted the transmission efficiency of glass was higher when surface tarnish was present on the glass surface. Understanding the phenomenon provided a foundation for later inventions and improvements in producing AR coatings at scale.
So how can tarnished glass transmit light more efficiently? The cause of this is related to the wave nature of light and the reflective nature of certain materials. When light is incident upon a transparent material’s surface at smaller angles of incidence, a significant percentage of the light propagates through the material, changing angle as it enters and leaves the material based on refractive index (Snell’s Law). A smaller percentage is reflected off the surface at an angle equal to the angle of incidence. Depending on the surface finish of the material, additional light can be lost due to surface scatter (haze).
This is related to Snell’s Law and how the angle of the image ray changes based on the curved surface angles. When you are observing another car’s windshield, and the sun hits at an angle and reflects light to your eyes, you can be blinded by the reflection. Finally, imagine the window glass is dirty and covered with road oil and grime. The glass appears hazy, and it is difficult to see through it clearly when light scatters off the contaminants, scratches, and pits on the glass surface.
If we want to maximize the amount of light transmitted through a transparent material (sapphire window), while reducing the amount of reflected light, we apply a coating of deliberate thickness and refractive index. A “perfect” coating can be calculated, but in practice, available coating materials, coating adhesion, and current coating processes limit attainment of the theoretical optimum. Additionally, we want to ensure the window is polished and free of contaminants. The coating interacts with light waves to create destructive interference on the rays that would reflect to the observer and creates constructive interference on the waves that continue through the window, thereby reducing the reflected light while increasing the amount of light transmitted through the sapphire window.
The simple example above describes a single-layer AR coating optimized for a particular wavelength. This approach works well when an optical system operates primarily at one wavelength, such as a laser system. However, many applications require transmission over a much wider range of wavelengths. In these cases, more complex coating designs can be used.
A single-layer coating is generally the simplest and most economical approach. The coating thickness and index of refraction can be selected to minimize reflection at a specific wavelength or over a relatively narrow range of wavelengths.
For applications requiring higher transmission over a broader range, multilayer AR coatings can be used. These coatings are made by depositing alternating layers of materials with different indices of refraction. By controlling the thickness and index of refraction of each layer, the coating reduces reflection over a much wider wavelength range than a single-layer coating.
Some applications require high transmission at two separate wavelength regions. For example, an optical system may need to operate in both the visible and infrared portions of the spectrum. These applications can use dual-band AR coatings that provide low reflectance at both wavelength regions.
Therefore, the appropriate coating design depends on the intended use of the sapphire window and the wavelengths that need to pass through it. A coating optimized for a single laser wavelength will have different requirements than a coating intended for a broadband imaging or sensing application.
The image below was taken from the paper Multilayer Reflectivity by John E. Davis, which describes the following. “This figure shows the possible paths of a photon within a multilayer that is composed of two dielectric slabs sandwiched between the vacuum at the top and a bulk substrate at the bottom. When the photon encounters the boundary between two layers, it either reflects or refracts. The shade and thickness of a photon line is used to denote the relative probability of the line.”
To determine how much light is reflected/transmitted, we can leverage equations derived from the work of Augustin-Jean Fresnel. Reflectance at a normal angle of incidence can be expressed as:
For this example, n0 is the refractive index of air (~ 1.00), and n1 is the refractive index of sapphire (~1.77). The reflectance at the interface between air and sapphire is ~7.7%. Calculating the exit of the light waves from the sapphire into air, we get another ~7.7%. For optically sensitive applications, reflectance of 8% is not trivial, and if needed, we would turn to the use of AR coatings to improve efficiency.
How then do we calculate the “perfect” AR coating? We will limit the depth of the discussion to a simple case and avoid digging too deep into the underlying physics, but a perfect, single-layer coating can be calculated using the index of refraction of the transparent material to determine the nominal index of refraction for the coating, and the thickness of the AR coating will be ¼ the wavelength of the light waves we are seeking to optimize.
Assuming an index of refraction of 1.77 for a sapphire window, the coating refractive index would be √1.77=1.33. If we were using a green laser at a wavelength of 532nm, then 532nm / 4= 133nm film thickness. Now we need a material with an index of refraction close to 1.33 and the ability to coat the sapphire surface with the material. Depending on the use of the window, we may want a coating that is durable, with a transparency over a wide range of wavelengths. One material that meets these requirements is magnesium fluoride: an affordable option that can reduce reflectance of sapphire to 0.4%!
Common AR Coating Materials
So, magnesium fluoride is one option, but what other materials can be used for AR coatings? The selection of the coating material, however, depends on the wavelength of interest, the desired optical performance, and the environment in which the sapphire window will be used. Other materials commonly used in optical coatings include silicon dioxide (SiO₂), hafnium oxide (HfO₂), and titanium dioxide (TiO₂).
Silicon dioxide has a relatively low index of refraction and is commonly used as part of multilayer coating designs. It also provides good chemical stability, low optical absorption, and good transmission over a broad wavelength range.
Hafnium oxide has a higher index of refraction and is often selected for demanding applications, particularly where high laser damage thresholds and thermal stability are important. Titanium dioxide also has a high index of refraction and can be used in multilayer coatings where a larger difference between the indices of refraction is desired.
The selection of these materials is not simply based on the index of refraction. The coating must also adhere to the sapphire surface, survive the intended operating environment, and maintain its optical performance over the required wavelength range. This is where the coating structure becomes more complex than the simple single-layer example described above.
Types of Anti-Reflective Coatings
As we move from a simple single-layer coating to more complex coating designs, the AR coating type we select depends on the application. Some applications require optimization at a single wavelength, while others need excellent transmission across a broad spectral range.
Single-Layer AR Coatings
Single-layer coatings are optimized for one primary wavelength and offer a cost-effective solution for reducing reflection. They are particularly useful for applications such as laser optics and sensors where the system operates primarily at one wavelength or within a relatively narrow range.
Broadband Multilayer AR Coatings
For applications requiring higher transmission over a broader range, multilayer AR coatings can be used. These coatings use alternating layers of high- and low-index dielectric materials to minimize reflection across a wider wavelength range. In addition to increasing transmission, broadband coatings can reduce stray light and improve imaging performance.
Dual-Band AR Coatings
Some optical systems require high transmission at two distinct wavelength bands, such as visible imaging combined with infrared sensing. Dual-band coatings are engineered specifically for these applications, allowing the coating to provide low reflectance at both wavelength regions.
More complex AR coatings can be applied to sapphire by layering various materials to achieve optimized performance over various wavelengths, and in some cases, single-layer coatings can be “tuned” over a range of refractive indices by controlling the microstructure of the coating.
Thin-Film Deposition Technologies
Once we have determined the wavelength requirements and selected the appropriate coating materials, the next consideration is how the coating is applied to the sapphire surface. Producing high-performance AR coatings requires precise deposition processes capable of controlling film thickness and uniformity. Several deposition techniques can be used depending on the application and the performance requirements of the coating.
Electron Beam Evaporation
A widely used process that offers excellent optical quality and efficient production for many commercial optical coatings.
Ion-Assisted Deposition (IAD)
Ion bombardment during deposition increases coating density, improves adhesion, and enhances environmental durability.
Magnetron Sputtering
Magnetron sputtering produces dense, uniform coatings with excellent adhesion and is commonly used in aerospace, semiconductor, and high-performance optical applications.
The selection of the deposition process depends on optical performance requirements, coating durability, and manufacturing considerations.
Selecting an AR Coating for a Sapphire Window.
So, how do we determine which AR coating is appropriate for a particular sapphire window? Before selecting a coating, it is important to understand how the sapphire window will be used and what the optical system is expected to achieve.
The operating wavelength is one of the most important considerations. A coating intended for a 532nm green laser, for example, will be different from a coating intended to provide high transmission across the visible spectrum or into the infrared.
The angle at which light enters the sapphire window should also be considered. The simple calculations shown earlier assume normal incidence, but the optical behavior of the coating changes as the angle of incidence increases. Polarization can also become an important consideration in applications where light enters the window at larger angles.
The operating environment is another important factor. A sapphire window may be exposed to high or low temperatures, vacuum, pressure, chemicals, humidity, abrasion, or high-power laser radiation. These conditions can influence the coating material and deposition process selected for the application.
Surface preparation is also important. Even though sapphire is extremely hard, the quality of the polished surface affects both the optical performance and the ability of the coating to adhere properly. Scratches, pits, contamination, and surface roughness can introduce scattering and reduce the overall efficiency of the optical system.
For these reasons, AR coating selection should be considered as part of the overall sapphire window application requirements rather than as a separate step added after the window has been manufactured.
Conclusion
Synthetic sapphire is a robust, versatile material that can deal with harsh conditions and is suitable for many applications such as sensors, cover lenses, viewports, pressure windows, and subsea imaging systems. Other applications include laser systems, spectroscopy, semiconductor equipment, UV optical instruments, aerospace sensors, defense optics, industrial imaging, and scientific instrumentation. It can withstand very high temperatures and is very resistant to many acids and alkalis, high-pressure and strong vacuum environments. This hard material should be at the top of the list of engineers looking for high performance in their specific applications at reasonable cost. AR coatings can further enhance the use of synthetic sapphire in a number of these critical applications by increasing transmission, reducing reflection, and improving the overall optical efficiency of the window.